Can a tenant request my insurance information after an accident?

Tenants and their attorneys can request whatever they want. Whether you have to produce it depends on the stage. If a lawsuit has actually been filed, discovery rules in most states let them request insurance agreements because they're relevant to whether there's coverage to collect. That's a court process though, not something they can demand by letter.

Get your own counsel before you send anything. A polite letter asking for insurance is not the same as a subpoena.

Also, disclosing members of the LLC is a separate question from the insurance policy. Don't volunteer the ownership structure because they asked.

I went through something similar with a commercial tenant. My carrier handled the request directly. I gave the claims adjuster the letter from their attorney and let the insurer respond. The policy was in the LLC's name, and that was all that got disclosed. The member names never came up. If there's an active claim, the insurer usually wants to be the one communicating anyway, since anything you say can affect coverage.

Does the lease say anything about insurance or indemnity? That might shape who responds.

They can ask. You aren't obligated to answer outside of litigation or a legal process. In many states a plaintiff can't just demand the policy pre-suit. Once suit is filed, insurance disclosure is routine. Members are harder to get at unless they pierce the veil or the LLC is a party and discovery is broad. Talk to a lawyer licensed in your state.

One thing people forget, some states require landlords to disclose insurance info to tenants under statute, but that's usually about renters insurance or habitability, not liability after an injury. Check your jurisdiction.

Right, and answer the easy part through the carrier. If the insurer confirms coverage, the tenant's attorney often stops pushing on who owns the LLC. The fight is usually about money, not names

Not always. Some attorneys pull the LLC's annual report from the secretary of state and use that. Whether members show up there varies by state.

Worth noting most annual reports lisy a registered agent, not members, unless your state requires member disclosure.